#religiousconditioning #religioustrauma #exevangelical #comingoutofthechurch #comingoutlaterinlife #purityculture
There's a particular kind of pain that comes from being taught, from day one, that you can't trust yourself. That your instincts are wrong. That your desires are sinful. That pain is what Morgan carried for most of her life.
When Morgan was 16, she started dating the man she would eventually marry at 18. By 28, she had built what looked like the perfect life on paper: a loving husband who was also her best friend, three beautiful children, a home in San Diego, and deep roots in her church community. But underneath all of that was a quiet knowing she'd been pushing down for years. A question she couldn't even articulate, let alone answer.
Growing up in a conservative Christian household, Morgan learned that trusting herself over God was a sin. It's a teaching that sounds abstract until you realize what it actually does. It dismantles your ability to trust anything about yourself. Not just your sexuality. Your instincts. Your gut feelings. Your desires. All of it becomes suspect.
So when feelings about women started surfacing in her late teens and early twenties, Morgan had no framework to even recognize them as real.
"I didn't relate to my peers who were having crushes on boys," Morgan explains. "But I just was like, guess this is just how you feel, this is normal, you know?"
It wasn't normal. Or rather, it was normal for her, but she had no language for it. No one around her had a similar experience. And the one person who did know her well, her husband, wasn't equipped to help her understand what was happening, because Morgan herself didn't understand it.
Instead, she cycled through explanations. It's the trauma. It's purity culture. It's postpartum depression. It's that she's asexual. It's that she's broken. Anything, really, except the thing that was actually true.
For years, Morgan found herself on what she describes as a "roller coaster"…periods of intense feelings and questions about her sexuality would surface so strongly that she'd dream about women every night, wake up feeling guilty, and spend her days questioning everything. The feelings would consume her mental energy until they became unbearable.
Then she'd suppress them.
She'd try to push the questions away, tell herself it was too uncomfortable to face, and for a little while, the intensity would fade. But the cycle would always repeat. Surface. Suppress. Surface again. It was exhausting and unsustainable, but it felt safer than actually confronting what might be true.
Even when her husband, in a moment of radical acceptance, told her that if she turned out to be a lesbian, he'd just want her to be happy, Morgan's response was immediate and visceral: "No, no, no, no, that's not it."
But there was something in that kernel of truth that terrified her. Not just because of the life she'd built, but because of everything she'd been taught about what it would mean. About hell. About sin. About belonging. About being accepted by the people she loved most.
The turning point came last year during an especially challenging family season. Morgan was fostering a baby, supporting family members through a crisis, and operating at absolute capacity. It was the worst possible time to process anything, which is precisely when everything came up.
She found herself sobbing in her car, feeling a grief so intense it almost knocked her over. It wasn't just grief about her current situation. It was grief about everything she'd missed out on, everything she might never get to experience, everything she'd spent years denying herself.
And in that moment of crisis, something shifted. She realized this wasn't going to go away on its own. She couldn't suppress it forever. The cost of staying was becoming as unbearable as the cost of leaving.
That's when she found Samantha Fox's content, and more specifically, the Bi Life community (now called Beyond Straight). It felt accessible. It felt like a way to finally work with someone who understood, someone who could help her face the thing she'd been avoiding fo
When Morgan joined the community, something remarkable happened. She heard other people's stories—stories that were different in the details but strikingly similar in the experience. She wasn't alone. She wasn't broken. She wasn't the only person who'd grown up in purity culture and found herself questioning her sexuality. She wasn't the only one who'd spent years cycling between surfacing and suppressing the truth.
"I can't just convince myself this isn't real anymore," Morgan realized, "because so many people are having this experience."
That's the power of community. It's not just emotional support, though it is that. It's evidence. It's proof that what you're feeling is real, that your experience matters, that you're not making it up or being dramatic or sinful or broken.
In twelve months, Morgan came out to her husband about her sexuality, opened their marriage, built a queer community from scratch, and came out to her deeply religious parents. She deconstructed from Christianity. She stopped running from the question.
And she finally started trusting herself again.
If you're reading this and you recognize yourself in Morgan's story, if you've been circling this question for years, stepping toward the door and then stepping back, wondering if what you feel is even real, this episode is for you.
It's real. Morgan's story is proof that when your system is ready, when you finally decide that the cost of staying the same is higher than the cost of change, everything can shift. Not easily, maybe. Not without fear. But it can shift.
And you don't have to do it alone.
---
Ready to hear Morgan's full story? Listen to "Raised to Not Trust Myself: How Could I Know I Was Gay?" on Unbox Yourself with Samantha Fox®. And if you're ready to take a step but don't know what that step is, explore the Beyond Straight community, a space where you can explore your sexuality, meet others on similar journeys, and finally start trusting yourself again.